Choosing a facial plastic surgeon is one of the most important decisions you will make if you are considering cosmetic surgery. There are credentials to verify, photographs to evaluate, techniques to understand and questions to ask. But I think there is something even more important: finding a surgeon who understands your anatomy, knows what can realistically be improved and is willing to explain why a particular operation makes sense for you.
Patients today have access to an extraordinary amount of information. You can watch surgical videos, research different facelift techniques, compare rhinoplasty results and read hundreds of reviews before ever scheduling a consultation.
That access is valuable. But it also creates confusion. I see patients who have spent months researching a particular procedure without necessarily knowing whether that procedure is right for their anatomy.
When I think about choosing a facial plastic surgeon, I want patients to look beyond the popularity of a technique, a surgeon’s social media presence or the price of an operation.
You are not simply choosing someone who knows how to perform a procedure. You are choosing someone who knows when to perform it, how to adapt it to your anatomy and when another approach may be better.
SURGICAL QUALIFICATIONS
What Board Certification Should a Facial Plastic Surgeon Have?
Board certification should be one of the first things you investigate. But I also want patients to understand exactly what that certification represents.
A medical license allows a physician to practice medicine. Board certification is an additional credential demonstrating that the physician has completed specified training and met examination and other requirements established by a certifying board.
The important distinction is the specialty in which the surgeon is certified.
Facial plastic surgery has two established surgical training pathways. Some surgeons complete a plastic surgery residency. Others complete an otolaryngology–head and neck surgery residency, which provides extensive training in the anatomy and surgery of the face, head and neck.
Both pathways can lead to additional specialization in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery.
The American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, or ABFPRS, requires qualifying residency training, prior certification in an accepted surgical specialty, documented surgical experience, peer review and successful completion of its examination process.
That is different from certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery. These are separate boards with different training and certification pathways, and patients should understand the distinction rather than assuming that every board-certified surgeon has the same background.
What Does Double Board Certification Mean?
Double board certification means that a physician has earned certification from two different certifying boards. It does not mean that every double board-certified surgeon has identical training.
In my case, I completed my residency in otolaryngology–head and neck surgery at UT Southwestern Medical Center, followed by fellowship training in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery.
I hold certification from the American Board of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery and the American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. You can review my complete surgical training, board certifications and curriculum vitae, including my research and publications.
That background influences how I approach facial surgery. I spent years studying the relationships between facial muscles, nerves, blood vessels, bone, cartilage and the deeper structures of the head and neck before concentrating my practice on facial plastic surgery.
But I do not believe patients should choose me, or any surgeon, based on certifications alone. Credentials establish an important foundation. Experience, judgment and actual surgical results still matter.
How Do You Verify a Plastic Surgeon’s Credentials?
You do not have to rely exclusively on what a surgeon writes on a website.
You can independently check board-certification information through the appropriate certifying organization, including the ABFPRS certification directory and the relevant American Board of Medical Specialties member board.
You can also verify whether a physician holds an active medical license and review publicly available disciplinary information through the appropriate state medical board.
In Texas, the Texas Medical Board physician lookup provides licensure information, professional background details and applicable board actions.
Patients should distinguish between being board eligible and board certified. Board eligible generally means that a physician has completed qualifying training and may be eligible to pursue certification. It does not mean the physician has already earned that certification.
I would also encourage patients to ask about fellowship training, ongoing education and the areas of surgery that make up the surgeon’s current practice.
Those questions give you a more complete understanding of the surgeon’s preparation than a title alone.
BEFORE & AFTER
Eyelid Surgery Results
EXPERIENCE THAT MATTERS
Does the Surgeon Regularly Perform Your Procedure?
Experience matters, but the type of experience matters just as much.
If you are considering a facelift, I would want you to know how much of the surgeon’s practice is devoted to facial rejuvenation. If you are considering rhinoplasty, I would want you to understand the surgeon’s experience working with nasal structure, breathing and both primary and revision procedures.
The same principle applies to eyelid surgery. The surgeon needs to understand more than how to remove excess skin. Eyelid position, support, fat distribution and the relationship between the eyes and cheeks all influence the operation.
Ask how frequently the surgeon performs the procedure you are considering. Ask whether they treat patients with anatomy similar to yours. Ask about their experience with difficult or revision cases.
I also think it is important to understand how surgeons make decisions when an operation does not fit neatly into one standardized technique.
For example, when I am evaluating facial aging, I look at the midface, jawline and neck together before deciding whether a deep plane facelift is appropriate. If volume loss or changes in skin quality are also contributing to the problem, I may discuss my 4D Facelift™ approach and the reasons for combining treatments.
That decision should come from examining the patient, not from trying to apply the same operation to everybody.
I want a surgeon to be able to explain not only how to perform an operation, but why that operation is appropriate for the anatomy in front of them.
BEYOND THE PROCEDURE NAME
Should You Choose a Surgeon Based on a Particular Technique?
I see this increasingly in consultations.
Patients arrive asking for a deep plane facelift, a preservation rhinoplasty or another procedure they have researched extensively. Sometimes they have correctly identified a technique that makes sense for their anatomy.
Other times, the name of the procedure has become more important than understanding what actually needs to be corrected.
I think surgeons contribute to that confusion. We use technical terms in our videos and marketing because they help describe what we do. But they can also give patients the impression that one named technique must be the best solution for everyone.
That is not how I think surgery should work.
I want patients to understand the anatomy. If I recommend a deep plane facelift, I should be able to explain which tissues need repositioning and why a deeper release would be useful.
If I recommend addressing additional areas of the face or combining procedures, I should be able to explain what each part of the treatment plan is intended to accomplish.
And if I do not believe surgery is the right answer, I should be comfortable telling the patient that.
A good consultation should explain the surgical reasoning, not simply confirm the procedure name you arrived with.
INSIGHTS FROM DR. ATHRÉ
Why I Don’t Want Patients Choosing Surgery by Its Name
I explain why patients sometimes become focused on terms such as deep plane facelift and how that can interfere with choosing the procedure that actually fits their anatomy. Understanding the surgeon’s reasoning is more useful than choosing a technique based on its name.
EVALUATING REAL RESULTS
What Should You Look for in Before and After Photos?
Before and after photographs are one of the most useful ways to evaluate a surgeon’s aesthetic approach. But I want patients to look at them carefully.
Do not simply find the most dramatic transformation on a website and assume that represents what every patient can expect.
Look at patients whose starting anatomy resembles yours. If you are evaluating facelifts, look for patients with similar facial structure, skin quality, jowling or neck aging.
For rhinoplasty, compare patients with similar nasal features and goals. A surgeon who produces beautiful results on one type of nose may need a different set of techniques when treating another.
I would also encourage you to examine the photographs in several ways.
Look for Consistent Photography
Head position, camera angle, lighting, facial expression and distance from the camera can change how a result appears.
If the before photograph uses harsh lighting while the after photograph uses soft, flattering light, the images become more difficult to compare accurately.
Standardized photographs help you evaluate the surgical result rather than changes in the photography itself. This is also emphasized in published facial plastic surgery photography guidelines.
Look Beyond the Most Obvious Improvement
In a facelift photograph, the jawline may be the first thing you notice. But I also look at the cheeks, mouth, ears, hairline and neck.
Does the face still look recognizable? Are the proportions natural? Does the improvement make sense across the entire face?
With rhinoplasty, I look at how the nose fits the face, not simply whether a dorsal hump has been removed or the tip has become smaller.
Ask When the Photographs Were Taken
Early postoperative photographs can be helpful, particularly when you want to understand recovery. But an early photograph and a photograph taken one year after surgery answer different questions.
Swelling changes over time. Scars mature. The tissues continue settling. A surgeon should be able to discuss what changes may still occur and whether longer-term results are available.
I would rather see a collection of consistent, natural-looking results than one spectacular photograph that tells me very little about the surgeon’s overall work.
BEFORE & AFTER
Facelift Results
PATIENT SAFETY
Where Will Your Surgery Be Performed?
The location where surgery takes place deserves as much attention as the surgeon’s credentials.
Facial plastic surgery may be performed in a hospital, an ambulatory surgery center or an appropriately equipped office-based surgical facility. Each setting has different capabilities and requirements.
I do not believe the building alone tells you whether surgery will be safe. The important questions involve the patient, the operation, the anesthesia, the qualifications of the team and the resources available if something unexpected occurs.
An accredited outpatient surgical facility can be appropriate for selected procedures and patients. In fact, a 2025 review of 42,720 outpatient plastic surgery cases found a low overall reported complication rate in an accredited setting, while emphasizing appropriate patient selection and the importance of evaluating surgical risk.
That does not mean every patient is an appropriate outpatient surgery candidate. Medical conditions, combined procedures, operative duration and anesthesia requirements all influence the decision.
How Do You Verify Facility Accreditation?
Ask whether the location where your surgery will actually take place holds appropriate accreditation and who issued it.
Organizations that accredit ambulatory or office-based surgical facilities include the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care, QUAD A and The Joint Commission.
Accreditation evaluates important aspects of facility operations and patient safety, but it is not a guarantee that complications cannot occur.
Ask who will administer anesthesia, what monitoring will be used, what emergency equipment is available and what the team would do if a patient needed transfer to a hospital.
If you want to understand more about the differences between surgical settings, I discuss them in Plastic Surgery Locations: What Facility Is Right for You?
Who Will Actually Perform Your Surgery?
Patients sometimes assume that the physician they meet during their consultation will personally perform every part of the operation.
It is reasonable to ask how the surgical team is organized.
Who will perform the critical portions of the procedure? Will another surgeon, resident, fellow or assistant participate? Who is responsible for anesthesia? Who will be present throughout the operation?
Having a surgical team is not a problem. Surgery often depends on the coordinated work of qualified professionals with different responsibilities.
What matters is that you understand who will be involved and what each person will be responsible for.
I would also ask who will provide postoperative care. Will you see your surgeon during recovery? If a concern develops after hours, how will you reach someone who can help?
These details can have a significant effect on how comfortable and supported you feel throughout the experience.
THE CONSULTATION
What Should Happen During a Facial Plastic Surgery Consultation?
I think the consultation is one of the most revealing parts of choosing a surgeon.
You should have an opportunity to explain what concerns you, what you hope to improve and what you do not want to change.
The surgeon should examine your anatomy, explain what they see and describe the available options.
That conversation should include the limits of surgery. No procedure can make every aspect of facial aging disappear, and no surgeon can guarantee a particular result.
I also think patients should feel comfortable disagreeing or asking for clarification.
If a surgeon recommends something more extensive than you expected, ask why. If the recommendation is more limited than you expected, ask whether that will accomplish your goals.
Research on patient-surgeon communication in aesthetic surgery emphasizes the importance of expectation management, especially when patients are influenced by heavily edited photographs and social media results.
A consultation should help you understand the operation well enough to make an informed decision, not leave you feeling pressured to schedule one.
I do not want a patient leaving a consultation simply knowing the name of the surgery I recommended. I want them to understand why I recommended it.
Pay Attention to What the Surgeon Is Willing to Say No To
One question I think patients should ask is whether the surgeon ever recommends against surgery.
There are patients whose anatomy does not require a particular procedure. There are patients whose goals may not be achievable with surgery. And there are patients whose health or circumstances mean that proceeding would not be appropriate.
If every consultation ends with a recommendation for the same operation, I would want to understand why.
The ability to recognize when not to operate is part of surgical judgment.
PATIENT EXPERIENCES
How Much Should You Trust Online Reviews?
Reviews can tell you things that surgical photographs cannot.
They may help you understand how the practice communicates, how patients feel during recovery and whether the team remains accessible after surgery.
I would look for patterns across a meaningful number of reviews rather than focusing exclusively on the highest rating or one particularly enthusiastic testimonial.
Pay attention to comments about the consultation, clarity of instructions, follow-up appointments and how concerns were addressed.
These are important parts of the patient’s overall experience.
A study of patients scheduling aesthetic surgery consultations found that online reviews, surgeon availability during follow-up and pricing information ranked among the factors patients considered most important.
But reviews have limitations. They are subjective experiences, and a high rating does not independently establish surgical skill, safety or the quality of long-term results.
I would use them alongside credential verification, photographs and the consultation itself.
You can review experiences shared by patients of our practice on our patient reviews page.
Should Price Determine Which Plastic Surgeon You Choose?
Cost is an important part of the decision. Facial plastic surgery is a significant financial commitment, and patients should have a clear understanding of what they are paying for.
But I would not choose a surgeon based on price alone.
Two quotations may represent very different operations. The surgical technique, anesthesia, facility, postoperative appointments and additional treatments included in the plan may not be identical.
Ask for a clear explanation of what the fee includes. Does it cover the surgeon, surgical facility and anesthesia? Are postoperative visits included? What costs might arise if an unexpected complication requires additional care?
Also ask what the surgeon expects the procedure to accomplish and whether there are less extensive options that would still address your concerns.
The least expensive option is not automatically the most economical decision if the procedure does not address the underlying problem. But a higher price, by itself, does not establish better quality either.
Our patient resources include additional information about the consultation process and available financing options.
LOCATION & FOLLOW-UP
Should You Travel to Another City for Plastic Surgery?
Many patients travel for facial plastic surgery because they have found a surgeon whose experience and results match what they are looking for.
I do not think patients should automatically limit their search to surgeons within a short drive of home. But travel creates additional responsibilities that need to be considered before surgery.
How long will you need to stay near the practice? Who will examine you during the early recovery period? What happens if you develop a problem after returning home?
If you are considering surgery in another country, you also need to understand the local regulatory environment, how to verify credentials and facility standards, and what access to medical care will be available afterward.
I would not assume every facility outside the United States is unsafe, just as I would not assume every facility in the United States provides the same level of care. Verification matters wherever you go.
For patients traveling to Houston, we explain postoperative visits, recommended length of stay and available recovery support on our out-of-town patients page.
Travel should be planned around the medical requirements of the operation, not simply the earliest available return flight.
INSIGHTS FROM DR. ATHRÉ
What to Expect When Traveling to Houston for Surgery
I explain how we coordinate virtual consultations, preoperative testing, travel arrangements and postoperative appointments for patients coming to Houston. I generally recommend staying near the practice for approximately 9 to 10 days after surgery, with the exact plan individualized to the operation and the patient’s recovery.
Is Getting a Second Opinion a Good Idea?
Absolutely, particularly if you are considering a complex operation, revision surgery or a procedure that you do not fully understand.
Different surgeons may approach the same anatomical problem differently. That does not automatically mean one is right and the other is wrong.
What matters is whether each surgeon can explain the reasoning, realistic benefits, limitations and risks behind the recommendation.
A second opinion may reveal that there are several reasonable ways to approach your concerns. It may also help you recognize when a proposed operation is more extensive than necessary.
I think an informed patient should feel comfortable asking difficult questions and taking time to consider the answers.
Choosing surgery should never feel like a decision that has to be made before you leave the consultation.
BEFORE MAKING YOUR DECISION
Questions I Would Ask Before Choosing a Facial Plastic Surgeon
If I were helping a friend or family member evaluate a surgeon, these are the questions I would want answered:
- Which surgical boards have certified you, and what residency and fellowship training did you complete?
- How often do you perform the operation I am considering?
- Can you show me results from patients with anatomy and concerns similar to mine?
- Why are you recommending this procedure instead of another approach?
- What are the realistic limitations and potential complications?
- Where will the surgery take place, and what accreditation does the facility hold?
- Who will perform the operation, who will administer anesthesia and who will manage an emergency?
- What does postoperative care include, and who will be available if I have a concern?
- What is included in the total cost, and what expenses might not be covered?
- Under what circumstances would you recommend that a patient not undergo surgery?
The answers should help you understand both the surgeon’s technical qualifications and the way they think about patient care.
The right surgeon is not necessarily the one offering the most elaborate operation. It is the one whose training, judgment, results and approach make sense for your particular situation.
How I Would Make the Final Decision
There is no single piece of information that tells you everything you need to know about a surgeon.
Board certification establishes training and examination credentials. Experience tells you what kinds of procedures the surgeon regularly performs. Before and after photographs demonstrate their aesthetic approach. Facility accreditation and the surgical team’s qualifications help you evaluate the environment where the operation will occur.
And the consultation gives you an opportunity to decide whether you understand and trust the surgeon’s reasoning.
My advice is to consider all of those things together.
Do your research. Look carefully at the results. Ask questions. Consider a second opinion when appropriate. Most importantly, make sure the proposed operation has been selected for your anatomy rather than because it happens to be popular.
You should leave your consultation understanding what the surgeon wants to accomplish, how they intend to accomplish it and what the limitations are. That understanding is an important part of choosing the right surgeon.
If you are considering facial surgery in Houston, you can schedule a consultation to discuss your concerns, examine your anatomy and learn which treatment options may be appropriate.
FREQUENTLY ASKED
Questions About Choosing a Facial Plastic Surgeon
These are some of the questions patients ask when comparing surgeon qualifications, experience, results and surgical safety.
What is the difference between a plastic surgeon and a facial plastic surgeon?
Plastic surgeons may train to perform reconstructive and cosmetic procedures across multiple areas of the body. Facial plastic surgeons focus on procedures involving the face, head and neck. The American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery recognizes qualifying training pathways through both plastic surgery and otolaryngology–head and neck surgery. The important question is whether the surgeon has appropriate training and experience for your particular operation.
Can an ENT surgeon become a board-certified facial plastic surgeon?
Yes. Otolaryngology–head and neck surgery is an established training pathway into facial plastic surgery. Surgeons who meet the additional requirements may pursue certification through the American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. Dr. Athré holds both otolaryngology–head and neck surgery and facial plastic and reconstructive surgery board certifications.
How can I check whether my surgeon is really board certified?
Ask for the exact name of the certifying board and verify the credential through that organization. The ABFPRS certification directory is one resource for facial plastic surgery certification. You can also verify a physician’s medical license through the applicable state licensing board rather than relying solely on advertising.
How important is experience with my specific procedure?
Procedure-specific experience is an important consideration, but no particular number of operations guarantees a result. A study of patient understanding of plastic surgery credentials found that patients placed particular importance on experience and board certification when selecting a provider. Ask how often the surgeon performs your procedure and how they approach cases similar to yours.
How do I know whether before and after photographs are reliable?
Look for comparable lighting, camera angles, expressions and patient positioning. A review of standardized photography in facial plastic surgery emphasizes that consistent equipment, lighting and positioning are essential for accurate photographic assessment. Ask when the photographs were taken and whether the surgeon has additional examples with similar anatomy.
Is it safe to have plastic surgery in an outpatient surgical center?
Outpatient surgery can be appropriate for properly selected patients when the facility, surgical team and anesthesia arrangements are suitable. A 2025 review of 42,720 outpatient plastic surgery cases reported a low overall complication rate in an accredited surgical center. However, complications remain possible, and safety depends on individual risk factors, the procedure and the resources available at the facility.
Should I choose the surgeon with the best online reviews?
Reviews can be helpful, but they should not be the only factor. A study of patient preferences before aesthetic surgery consultations found that online reviews, surgeon involvement in follow-up and pricing transparency were important to patients. Reviews can offer insight into communication and patient experience, but they cannot independently verify technical skill or long-term surgical outcomes.
What should I ask about complications during a consultation?
Ask about the complications associated with your specific procedure, how they are recognized and treated, and what happens if additional medical care becomes necessary. A study of expectations and informed consent in cosmetic surgery emphasizes the need for clear communication during presurgical consultations. A surgeon should be willing to discuss risks and limitations without dismissing your concerns.
Is it reasonable to get a second opinion before plastic surgery?
Yes. A second opinion can help you compare treatment recommendations, understand alternatives and feel more comfortable with the decision. Research on expectation management and patient-surgeon communication in aesthetic surgery emphasizes the importance of informed discussion and realistic expectations. The goal is to understand why a procedure has been recommended rather than selecting a surgeon solely because they agree with your initial preference.